In The Quantity Ones, I’m reviewing each single #1 single within the historical past of the Billboard Sizzling 100, beginning with the chart’s starting, in 1958, and dealing my approach up into the current.
Have been Savage Backyard ever well-known? Have been they stars? These two nondescript Australians had been positively in style. Savage Backyard’s self-titled 1997 debut went platinum seven instances over, and it launched a few singles into the highest 10 of the Billboard Sizzling 100, together with the #1 hit “Actually Madly Deeply.” However both of the members of Savage Backyard may’ve robbed me at knifepoint, and I nonetheless wouldn’t have been in a position to choose them out of a police lineup. Each period of pop music has artists like that — comparatively faceless figures who nonetheless rack up critical hits. However Savage Backyard by no means appeared to grasp that they had been nameless hitmakers, or possibly they had been unwilling to just accept that actuality. This lends them a wierd kind of appeal, even when their second and last #1 hit was transparently and cynically written to turn into a #1 hit.
Whereas Savage Backyard singer Darren Hayes wrote the songs from the band’s sophomore LP Affirmation, his life was falling aside. Hayes had gotten married earlier than Savage Backyard took off, and he sang about lacking his spouse on “Actually Madly Deeply.” However in the identical yr that “Actually Madly Deeply” reached #1, Hayes and his spouse cut up up. A couple of years later, Hayes got here out as homosexual. By that point, Savage Backyard had been damaged up. Hayes’ bandmate Daniel Jones, uncomfortable with no matter degree of fame that Savage Backyard had earned, advised Hayes that he wished to depart the band whereas they had been ending up Affirmation. Jones agreed to stay round for lengthy sufficient to tour behind the report, however a chapter was ending.
Apparently, Darren Hayes put all that non-public turmoil into Affirmation. Apparently, Hayes used the album to sort out heavy topics: Poisonous relationships, youngster abuse, his personal unfolding private crises. I say “apparently” as a result of the album nonetheless hits my ears as glassy, inoffensive, barely-there pop music. The lyrics fill the house simply tremendous, however they don’t seize me in any respect. These songs could be essential to Hayes, however Affirmation by no means pronounces its significance, the way in which so many heavy-subject pop data do. Perhaps that’s to Savage Backyard’s credit score. Perhaps they had been formidable sufficient to fulfill their very own inventive impulses however not so formidable that their music ever vacillated from what their followers wished. (Savage Backyard should’ve had followers, proper?) Perhaps that places them in a candy spot, although it doesn’t precisely cease them from being faceless.
Even when Darren Hayes used Affirmation to specific every thing that he had on his thoughts, his artiste impulses didn’t cease the group from working with a big-deal pop-music skilled. In 1999, Savage Backyard had been requested to contribute a tune to the soundtrack of the Garry Marshall movie The Different Sister, an completely forgotten rom-com the place Juliette Lewis and Giovanni Ribisi play younger folks with developmental disabilities who fall in lovex. Seems to be wildly offensive! (I needed to verify Wikipedia to make sure that The Different Sister really existed. Films like which are the rationale my Field Workplace Recreation rating stays abysmal.) Columbia Information boss Don Ienner instructed that Savage Backyard knock out a tune with Walter Afanasieff, the man who’d been Mariah Carey’s chief collaborator up till the second when Mariah didn’t wish to take care of her ex-husband Tommy Mottola’s buddies anymore.
In my thoughts, Savage Backyard and Walter Afanasieff make a superbly pure pairing. Afanasieff had made a complete lot of cash for Columbia, and he already had his identify on a complete lot of hits. Savage Backyard, in the meantime, made adult-contempo radio-bait; they weren’t precisely cranking out uncooked fever-dream howls. However the pairing appeared odd to each Afanasieff and Savage Backyard. In Fred Bronson’s Billboard E-book Of #1 Hits, Afanasieff says that Savage Backyard had been on the lookout for an “edgy man” and that he wasn’t certain he match the invoice: “I’m not recognized to supply rock ‘n’ roll acts. I’m stereotyped as a pop and possibly even a ballad producer.” (That’s in all probability not the right utilization of the phrase “stereotyped.” For those who produce sufficient big-hit ballads, it’s truthful for folks to make some assumptions. It doesn’t imply anybody is discriminating in opposition to you.)
Regardless of their perceived variations, Savage Backyard and Walter Afanasieff agreed to fulfill up in Afanasieff’s Bay Space studio, and that led to them making the breezy, falsetto-happy dance-pop jam “The Animal Music.” That monitor sort of guidelines, and it did effectively. Regardless that The Different Sister was a critically derided flop, “The Animal Music” peaked at #19 on the Sizzling 100 and did even higher in different nations. Savage Backyard had been so pleased with the end result that they requested Afanasieff to co-produce their Affirmation album.
Once they turned Affirmation in to Columbia, Savage Backyard had been happy with the end result, however their label boss didn’t suppose the album was fairly achieved but. Right here’s how Darren Hayes describes Don Ienner’s response to the album within the Fred Bronson ebook: “It’s a creative masterpiece. It’s unbelievable. You’ve grown. You’ve matured. It’s great. However there’s no ‘Actually Madly Deeply’ in right here.” If that’s actually Don Ienner’s response to Affirmation, then you may’t accuse the man of not supporting his artists. Affirmation is tremendous, however I’ve a tough time believing that anybody ever thought-about it a masterpiece. In any case, guys like Don Ienner exist virtually completely to inform artists that they don’t hear a single, and the person was simply doing his job.
Ienner didn’t really inform Savage Backyard that they wanted a single. As an alternative, he relayed that message to Walter Afanasieff. Right here’s Afanasieff’s story about breaking the information to the duo: “Darren is a insurgent. He likes to combat the institution. So it was actually troublesome. I eased it into the dialog, and it was like a dare. He acquired a glance in his eyes.” In Afanasieff’s model of the story, Hayes and Daniel Jones mentioned that certain, tremendous, they’d write one other “Actually Madly Deeply.” They went off into one other room and got here again 10 minutes later with “I Knew I Beloved You” absolutely written. A couple of years in the past, Hayes advised Official Charts that it really took Savage Backyard 40 minutes to give you “I Knew I Beloved You” and that they wrote the tune “out of spite in the direction of the report firm.”
“I Knew I Beloved You” doesn’t sound like a tune written out of any kind of spite in the direction of anybody. It does sound a bit like somebody attempting to recapture the magic of “Actually Madly Deeply,” however that’s not precisely a revolutionary factor. Musicians have been attempting to recreate the formulation of their previous hits ever since hit songs first existed. (I’m presently studying Bob Stanley’s new ebook Let’s Do It: The Delivery Of Pop, concerning the pre-rock ‘n’ roll years of in style music, and it’s fairly clear that songwriters had been trying to ape themselves even when songs had been being consumed as printed sheets of lyrics and musical notations.) It’s not rebellious to jot down a cynical hit. It’s the reverse of rebellious. Hayes may’ve meant “I Knew I Beloved You” as some sort of fuck-you assertion, however that’s not how the tune comes off.
As an alternative, “I Knew I Beloved You” is pure high-grade sap, a tune that screams “first marriage ceremony dance” from its opening line on down. Early in 2000, marriage ceremony ballads just about swallowed up the Sizzling 100 for a couple of months. Each tune that’ll seem within the column this week may perform as a marriage ballad. My working idea there’s that Individuals had been all wound up and stressed concerning the looming Y2K apocalypse. When nothing occurred, possibly some plurality of Individuals breathed an extended sigh of aid, and possibly their ideas turned towards goopy romanticism. (Perhaps I used to be a part of that. I didn’t actually fuck with any of these marriage ceremony ballads, however I positively thought I used to be absolutely in love throughout that stretch. As soon as a month, I’d make six-hour Greyhound journeys from Syracuse to New York to go to my girlfriend. We moved into an residence in Sundown Park that summer season, after which we broke up as quickly as the varsity yr began once more, as one does.)
“I Knew I Beloved You” doesn’t have the identical foolish majesty as “Actually Madly Deeply.” The tune feels somewhat smaller and somewhat extra canned, nevertheless it nonetheless sounds good sufficient. Darren Hayes sings about feeling like his beloved stepped out of his unconscious: “I knew I beloved you earlier than I met you/ I believe I dreamed you into life.” That’s a type of romantic writing that’s all the time appeared a bit off to me. You’re not speaking about this different individual, about what’s particularly nice about them. As an alternative, you’re speaking about your self, about how joyful you might be that another person displays all of the issues that you just wished.
Hayes’ verses go in a distinct instructions. They’re all about how essential it’s to cease questioning and comply with your instinct while you meet somebody who goes to play a task in your life. There’s nothing sketchy about that half. Its sense of abandon, no less than for me, rings true. Additionally, this line is fairly humorous: “A thousand angels dance round you/ I’m full now that I’ve discovered you.” What a bizarre option to paraphrase Renée Zellweger. Personally, I’m glad that I don’t have a thousand angels dancing round me. Think about the claustrophobia! And all of the feathers!
Musically, “I Knew I Beloved You” is completely strong mid-grade millennial adult-contempo fluff. It doesn’t keep on with my ribs the way in which a number of the goopy ballads of that period do. (Fairly quickly after “I Knew I Beloved You” pale out, acts like Coldplay and Dido had been throughout American radio, and people motherfuckers had been fairly constantly kicking me proper within the soul.) However “I Knew I Beloved You” nonetheless does the trick. Guitars twinkle. Synths sparkle. Darren Hayes hits some large, buttery falsetto notes. The important thing change arrives on the precise second while you’d anticipate, and it’s no much less efficient for its obviousness. It’s the very image of a tune that I’d by no means hunt down however that I’d fortunately ignore if it got here on the radio.
The video for “I Knew I Beloved You” got here from director Kevin Bray, who would quickly make All About The Benjamins and the Strolling Tall remake with the Rock. (Nowadays, Bray is a prolific TV man.) The clip takes place on a New York subway automotive that’s actually a backlot set. You may inform as a result of everybody on the practice is far more luminous and fewer harried any anybody on an precise New York subway has ever been. The video tells a love story between Darren Hayes and the very cute, very younger Kirsten Dunst. Dunst had simply been in The Virgin Suicides and Dick, and he or she was effectively on her option to turning into a film star; 2000 was the yr of Convey It On. It’s somewhat bizarre to see this model of Dunst in a New York romance with anybody aside from Tobey Maguire’s Peter Parker, however we had been nonetheless a yr and a half out from Spider-Man.
Savage Backyard may’ve written “I Knew I Beloved You” as a resentment-based homework project, however Darren Hayes has mentioned that he discovered to like the tune quickly sufficient: “It actually healed my damaged coronary heart. It’s such an harmless tune, and my approach of relating to like at the moment was to consider idealism and possibly the longer term.” In 2001, Afanasieff married his first spouse, and Darren Hayes sang “I Knew I Beloved You” on the marriage ceremony. (“I Knew I Love You” was the final #1 hit that Walter Afanasieff has produced, however he’ll be on this column once more, for a tune that he labored on years earlier.) By the point of Afanasieff’s marriage ceremony, Savage Backyard had been achieved.
Savage Backyard adopted “I Knew I Beloved You” with the equally forgettable “Crash And Burn,” which peaked at #24. That was the duo’s final time on the Sizzling 100. Affirmation went triple platinum. In 2001, Darren Hayes confirmed the rumors that Savage Backyard had been no extra. Within the years since then, Savage Backyard have launched a couple of greatest-hits collections — all the time humorous when the band in query solely made two albums — and so they haven’t ever reunited. A couple of years in the past, Hayes advised Official Charts that he and Daniel Jones weren’t shut anymore and that possibly they by no means had been: “It took me some time to understand that we had been by no means actually correct buddies on the time, and I believe that was a aware choice on Daniel’s half. As soon as he turned well-known, he didn’t prefer it and have become a recluse. I nonetheless couldn’t actually let you know who he’s as an individual.”
Daniel Jones went on to start out a recording studio and to supply a couple of Australian acts who by no means went wherever. He’s married with children now, and he’s now not within the music enterprise. As of this 2015 interview, Jones was flipping homes in Las Vegas.
Darren Hayes got here out of the closet, began up a solo profession, and ultimately acquired married once more. 2002’s “Insatiable,” his first solo single, peaked at #77, and he hasn’t been again on the Sizzling 100 since. In Australia and the UK, Hayes has had much more lasting success, and he’s nonetheless placing out data now. To date in 2022, Hayes has launched three singles. It looks as if each Savage Backyard guys at the moment are dwelling joyful and comparatively low-key lives. I’m joyful for each of them, though I nonetheless wouldn’t acknowledge them in the event that they had been standing proper in entrance of me.
BONUS BEATS: Right here’s the nation model of “I Knew I Beloved You” that the late Daryle Singletary launched in 2000:
(Daryle Singletary’s solely Sizzling 100 hit, 1997’s “The Be aware,” peaked at #90.)
The Quantity Ones: Twenty Chart-Topping Hits That Reveal The Historical past Of Pop Music is out 11/15 through Hachette Books. You may pre-order it right here.